Not So Fast, Google: That Lenient Monopoly Ruling from Last Year Is Being Appealed

Not So Fast, Google: That Lenient Monopoly Ruling from Last Year Is Being Appealed

By Mike Pearl
Publication Date: 2026-02-04 00:59:00

Tech god-kings like Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai tend to win in the courts when it matters, and there’s very little chance that’s about to change, but there’s just the tiniest glimmer of hope all of a sudden.

Legal filings reported Tuesday by Bloomberg indicated that the ruling from September of last year in which Google basically got to continue being a monopoly without significant consequences could be getting another look. The entity that originally brought suit against Google, comprising multiple states and the Justice Department, is appealing that ruling. Should that make you optimistic? Probably not, but at least it’s happening.

In August of 2024, District Judge Amit P. Mehta ruled—to the surprise of many—that Google was a monopolist. Google, it was determined, had acted illegally to maintain its stranglehold on the search market. 

Google controls 90% of the search engine market, and does it stay on top like this by being the best? Anecdotally, you…