Should you give Sargamis the relic in Avowed?

Dawntreader is likely to be the moment you realise that Avowed doesn’t shy away from asking difficult questions even in side quests. On this occasion, it’s whether you should let another godlike use the souls of innocents to bring back their (likely still evil) god, Eothas. Just another day for the Envoy, really. The Sargamis choice being so intertwined with the main story doesn’t make things any easier though–it even impacts your ending slightly.

Making matters worse, one of the